
The European Commission is developing renewable energy policies for the transport sector under the post-2030 energy framework, with particular emphasis on the Renewable Energy Directive (REDIII). As EU priorities shift toward energy independence and domestic industry support, there is mounting pressure to increase the role of first-generation biofuels derived from food and feed crops in the transport energy mix.
Researchers have analyzed three distinct policy scenarios to assess the potential consequences for climate, environment, and food security. The analysis reveals that the existing cap on first-generation biofuels under REDIII could permit a 72% increase in food and feed-crop biofuel consumption compared to 2024 levels. When indirect land use change is considered, current emissions from first-generation biofuels already reach approximately 43 megatons of CO2 equivalent annually, representing about 23% more than the fossil fuels they displace.
Under baseline safeguards similar to those in REDIII, biofuel volumes, land use, and emissions could potentially double by 2040, equating to emissions from over 5 million diesel vehicles. If caps are harmonized at 7% across all EU member states’ transport sectors, volumes and emissions could nearly triple. The most adverse scenario models a 10% cap, which could quadruple current levels by 2040, consuming 17.7 million hectares of land—approximately 18% of EU arable land and an area exceeding Greece’s size—while emissions would exceed fossil fuel emissions by 33 megatons of CO2 equivalent annually.
The analysis also addresses advanced and waste-derived biofuels, noting that current road sector consumption exceeds sustainable supply levels. These feedstocks should be directed toward sectors that cannot be electrified, such as aviation. The research highlights concerns regarding third-country export fraud and recommends phasing out palm oil derivatives while implementing robust safeguards to ensure the most sustainable feedstock options are prioritized.
Article Attribution | Read More at Article Source
Article summary produced by Claude AI