California DAs sue Gavin Newsom to stop death sentence commutations

by | Nov 17, 2026 | Politics

California DAs sue Gavin Newsom to stop death sentence commutations

California district attorneys representing 30 of the state’s 58 counties filed a lawsuit challenging Governor Gavin Newsom’s mass clemency action announced earlier this month. The legal challenge seeks to prevent the commutation of all 548 people currently facing execution in the state, which would represent the largest clearing of any death row in modern U.S. history.

The prosecutors and victims’ advocates argue that Newsom exceeded his authority and failed to provide proper notice to district attorneys and families of victims before proceeding with the blanket commutation. They contend the governor violated established procedures by not giving interested parties an opportunity to weigh in on the clemency decision. Newsom has countered that his constitutional clemency authority permits him to issue broad commutations of his own initiative, requiring notice only when ruling on individual prisoner applications. The commutations would result in the death-sentenced individuals receiving life sentences without possibility of parole instead.

Newsom made the announcement as his governorship was concluding, stating he had a moral obligation to oppose state-sanctioned executions and noting that California houses the largest death row in the western hemisphere. He previously enacted a moratorium on executions and dismantled the death row facility at San Quentin prison, allowing condemned inmates to leave solitary confinement.

The lawsuit is backed by prosecutors from major counties including Los Angeles, San Diego, Riverside, and Sacramento. However, prosecutors from Santa Clara and Contra Costa counties released statements supporting the commutations, characterizing the death penalty as outdated and ineffective. Newsom has also submitted a letter to the California Supreme Court requesting approval for commutations affecting 382 prisoners convicted of multiple felonies, as state law requires judicial approval in such cases.

Opposition to the commutations is not uniform among those affected by crime. Family members of some victims have endorsed the clemency action, including the sisters of Polly Klaas, a child killed in 1993. A former California corrections official also expressed support for Newsom’s decision, citing risks of executing innocent people, noting that at least eight people on the state’s death row have been exonerated over recent decades.

Article Attribution | Read More at Article Source

Article summary produced by Claude AI