
Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, has requested a police investigation into corporate homicide following revelations that at least 19 patients died from avoidable complications linked to surgery at the hospital. Habib stated he had raised concerns about the institution’s liver and pancreatic surgery unit starting from 2021, and believes the death toll may extend to dozens of patients. He has alleged that senior officials at NHS Grampian, the health board operating the facility, failed to respond with appropriate urgency to his reports.
An expert review commissioned by NHS Grampian and published recently examined allegations from Habib and another whistleblower. The investigation confirmed that 19 patients died due to serious adverse events stemming from surgery between 2015 and 2021. External experts conducting the 2022 review, both surgery professors from Edinburgh and Leeds universities, determined that the mortality rate in the liver and pancreatic surgery unit reached 18% between 2017 and 2020, substantially exceeding the national average of 2-3% for the same specialty depending on patient conditions.
Following publication of the expert findings, additional cases emerged. Habib identified four patients who died during or after surgery after the expert report’s completion. In March 2026, another external specialist deemed it critical that surgery operations cease at the facility, citing persistent elevated mortality rates in complex procedures as indicative of systemic dysfunction. The liver and pancreatic surgery department was subsequently closed.
The controversy represents the latest in a series of crises at NHS Grampian, which have included closure of pediatric surgery services at Gray’s hospital, replacement of board leadership, and independent inquiries into other serious adverse events. Scotland’s health secretary recently indicated the health board faces potential placement into special measures if current reforms proceed insufficiently. Healthcare Improvement Scotland identified serious leadership shortcomings but documented only one patient death from serious adverse events in its separate report.
Scotland’s first minister characterized Habib’s disclosures as extraordinarily concerning and acknowledged the NHS’s legal obligations regarding patient care and prompt investigation of safety failures. However, he declined demands for a criminal investigation. Habib’s solicitor called for the lord advocate to instruct a police investigation and urged immediate placement of NHS Grampian into special measures.
Article Attribution | Read More at Article Source
Article summary produced by Claude AI