
The Scottish government has commissioned an independent review into hepatobiliary surgery practices at NHS Grampian after a leaked 2022 report revealed significant patient safety concerns. Dr. Mohammed Habib, a whistleblower, disclosed documentation indicating 19 of 31 deaths in liver and pancreatic surgery cases were avoidable. Habib stated he had raised these concerns with the Scottish government on four separate occasions, as well as with police and the lord advocate, prior to the public disclosure.
Health Secretary Angela Constance announced the urgent review will assess how concerns about liver, gallbladder and bile duct surgery were handled by NHS Grampian and the Scottish government. The review aims to identify governance weaknesses, missed opportunities, unreasonable delays, and accountability gaps. Constance characterized Habib’s concerns as “deeply concerning and of the utmost seriousness” and stated the review would determine whether patient safety protocols were properly followed. She indicated that a statement outlining the review’s timetable and leadership would be presented in the Scottish Parliament.
NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight pledged the board would demonstrate “open and transparency” in cooperating with the investigation. The health board announced immediate steps to secure and preserve relevant information and records. Additionally, an external intervention support team of experienced senior NHS leaders has been appointed to work alongside NHS Grampian’s management to provide intensive turnaround support and improvements.
One patient, Derek Appleton, described undergoing liver surgery at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary where he stated mistakes occurred during a procedure to remove 60% of his liver. He reported experiencing severe blood loss and cardiac arrest without receiving adequate explanation. Healthcare Improvement Scotland has been tasked with completing an early review within three months, with ongoing assessments to follow.
Former Health Secretary Humza Yousaf, who later became and subsequently resigned as First Minister, stated support for “further dramatic action” regarding NHS Grampian. Political figures across the Scottish Parliament called for transparency and accountability, with some questioning why intervention did not occur sooner following Habib’s repeated warnings and the 2022 report findings.
Article Attribution | Read More at Article Source
Article summary produced by Claude AI