
A Toll Transport employee was terminated from his position as an LPG tanker driver following an incident involving the use of smartglasses at a fuel terminal in Victoria. The worker, Ricardo Martins Silva, was employed for eight months before his dismissal in July 2025, according to a federal circuit court judgment issued last week.
The incident occurred on 17 June 2025 when Martins Silva raised safety concerns about a truck assigned to him, citing excessive vibration. After being directed to select a different vehicle, he proceeded to the Long Island Point terminal in Hastings and used smartglasses to capture photographs, which he transmitted to a supervisor along with a message indicating his intention to return the truck and cease deliveries for the day. An Esso worker at the terminal subsequently informed Toll that any electrical equipment use on-site poses inherent safety risks due to potential explosion hazards from electrical sparks.
Following the incident, Martins Silva was restricted from taking additional work pending investigation. Origin Energy requested his removal from duties, citing concerns about his attitude and reluctance to complete scheduled deliveries due to fatigue and stress. Between 17 and 19 June, the employee submitted multiple emails regarding his role, truck allocation, and safety concerns. On 20 June, he filed a formal complaint addressing employment, safety, and health-related matters. He was placed on stand-down on 22 June and later suspended, with his employment terminated on 18 July after Toll determined that photographing with the smartglasses violated the company’s code of practice.
Martins Silva contested the dismissal under the Fair Work Act, arguing that Toll’s actions resulted from complaints he had made. However, the federal circuit court ruled that the glasses incident constituted an objectively serious safety violation. The judgment noted that the worker was aware of the risks and had attempted mitigation by covering the smartglasses with safety glasses. While Martins Silva referenced trauma from a prior truck fire in March 2025 as affecting his judgment, the court found he was dismissed specifically for wearing smartglasses rather than for making complaints.
The case emerges as governments across Australia grapple with broader regulatory questions surrounding smartglasses technology, with various councils implementing restrictions in public facilities and federal authorities exploring potential bans in government offices.
Article Attribution | Read More at Article Source
Article summary produced by Claude AI