A nuclear blast could save Earth from an asteroid, but there’s a catch

by | Nov 12, 2026 | Science

A nuclear blast could save Earth from an asteroid, but there's a catch

Researchers at Sandia National Laboratories have developed advanced computer simulations showing that the direction of a nuclear X-ray burst significantly impacts how effectively an asteroid can be deflected from Earth’s path. The study, published in Icarus, found that irradiating an asteroid from different angles produces vastly different results in terms of velocity change and rotational effects, with some simulations showing nearly fivefold variations in deflection velocity and 17-fold differences in rotational changes depending on blast direction.

To conduct this research, physicist Nathan Moore and colleagues created what they describe as the most accurate asteroid deflection model to date. Previous computer models faced a major limitation: researchers had to choose between accurately representing an asteroid’s complex, irregular shape and performing detailed calculations of physical forces. The new system overcomes this constraint by combining two sophisticated simulation approaches—ALEGRA code, typically used for high-energy experiments, and SPARTA, a direct simulation Monte Carlo code usually applied to weak, slowly-evolving forces. The resulting algorithm is over 1,600 times faster than earlier models, enabling scientists to study realistic asteroid shapes while maintaining computational precision.

A key breakthrough in the research involved abandoning the common practice of treating asteroids as smooth spheres in calculations. Real asteroids have uneven surfaces, ridges, depressions, and irregular shapes that significantly affect how they respond to radiation. The new model allows researchers to reconstruct asteroids using 3D images from spacecraft flybys and simulate nuclear X-ray bursts while adjusting explosion strength, distance, and direction. The software calculates material vaporization across the asteroid’s surface, estimated push effects, rotational changes, and surface damage.

Despite these advances, limitations remain. The current model can only predict breakup of surface rocks, not potential fragmentation of an entire asteroid body, which would require additional research and more advanced computational tools. However, the findings provide valuable guidance for future planetary defense missions. According to Moore, careful aim selection is critical: “Pick the right side and you win. Guess wrong and it could be a bad day.” The simulation tools could eventually help mission planners identify optimal blast parameters needed to move a threatening asteroid away from Earth, though implementing such a mission would remain extremely challenging.

Article Attribution | Read More at Article Source

Article summary produced by Claude AI